How much fertilizer does canola need?

February 7, 2018 - Issue 2

Canola generally needs nitrogen, phosphorus and sulphur fertilizer each year. A small percentage of fields will also benefit from a potassium application.

The following article suggests what canola needs and what soil and crop residue could provide. The rest will come from fertilizer.

Nitrogen

Overall need: The Canadian Fertilizer Institute factsheet, “Nutrient Uptake and Removal by Field Crops,” produced in 2001, says nitrogen uptake for a 35 bu./ac. canola crop is 100-123 lb./ac. of actual N. That works out to 2.9 to 3.5 pounds of available N per bushel of seed yield.

In 2005, Rigas Karamanos, a soil scientist with decades of experience in western Canada, published results from a Western Canada study* that found high-performance hybrid canola could generate much higher yields than non-hybrids using the same applied nitrogen rates. He found that with higher yields (say 50 bu./ac. or more), nitrogen uptake for hybrids was as low as 2.1 lb./bu.

As of 2018, Karamanos says an appropriate range for nitrogen uptake is 2 to 3 pounds of available N per bushel of seed yield.**

Soil reserves: Soil tests will indicate soil reserves, but available carryover nitrogen can be difficult to predict. Often about half the soil test N is immobilized and not available to this year’s crop.

Mineralization of soil organic matter (OM) will provide available nitrogen to the crop, but the amount varies widely based on soil type, soil OM levels and moisture. In general, OM can generate 6 to 30 pounds of available nitrogen per acre for each percentage point of OM. Rigas Karamanos uses 14 lb./ac. per OM%. Of that amount, only 80% is available to the crop that year. Using Karamanos’s number, soil with 4% OM will supply 45 lb./ac. of N through the growing season (4 x 14 x 0.80 = 45). He adds that mineralization can increase by up to 25% with more than average moisture be 25% lower in drier conditions, which makes predicting mineralization rates a challenge.

Losses should also be considered. High straw loads and poor fertilizer placement (such as broadcasting) mean more N than normal may be immobilized or temporarily tied up early in the season when canola is needing nitrogen. North Dakota State University (NDSU) estimates about 30 lb./ac. of N is immobilized for every ton per acre of cereal straw.

Of the N canola takes up, around 70% is removed with the seed and 30% is returned to the field in the residue.

Canola Encyclopedia chapter on nitrogen management

Phosphorus

Overall need: According to the CFI factsheet of 2001, a 35 bu./ac. canola crop takes up 46 to 57 lb./ac. of phosphate (P2O5). That works out to 1.3 to 1.6 lb./bu. Current recommendations are rounded to 1.25 to 1.5 pounds. A 50 bu./ac. canola crop would therefore need 62.5 to 75 lb./ac. of available phosphate.

Of the phosphate canola takes up, around 67% is removed with the seed and 33% is returned to the field in crop residue.

Soil reserves: If soil tests show available P levels at less than 10 parts per million (20 lb./ac.), this is considered “low” and growers may want to use a rate higher than crop removal to build soil reserves. At a soil test of 10-20 ppm, rates that match removal are recommended.

For a 50 bu./ac. canola crop, the “removal” rate would be over 40 lb./ac. of phosphate (80 lb./ac. of MAP, for example). Of that, a safe seed-placed rate of 20 lb./ac. of phosphate will ensure that canola has access to phosphate fertilizer and the benefit of early pop up, which is especially important when seeding into cool soils with low P levels, into soils with pH outside the sweet spot of 6.5-7, and in short-season areas. The rest can go with the nitrogen blend placed outside the seed row, ideally in a band.

Canola Encyclopedia chapter on phosphorus management

Sulphur

Overall need: Canola needs 0.5 to 0.8 pounds of sulphur (S) per bushel of yield, making it a high S-using crop. The high end of this range is higher than what was stated in the CFI 2001 factsheet.

A 50 bu./ac. canola crop needs 30 to 40 lb./ac. of available S. Of the S canola takes up, around 55% is removed with the seed and 45% is returned to the field in the residue.

Soil reserves: Fertilizer rate recommendations are based on the total need (uptake) minus the soil reserves, however a fair estimation of soil reserves is not always possible with a soil test. That’s because S is often highly variable across a field – it might be 10 pounds per acre in one corner and 2,000 pounds in another. If soil is low in S, fertilize according to soil test recommendations. If soil is moderate or high in S, some S in the fertilizer blend – say 10-15 lb./ac. – may be required to offset the high amount of S-test variability in a field.

Canola Encyclopedia chapter on sulphur management

Potassium

Overall need: Canola plants need 2.3-2.5 pounds of potassium (K2O) for every bushel of seed yield. (The CFI factsheet had the range at 2 to 2.5 lb./bu. for a 35 bu./ac. canola crop.) A 50 bu./ac. crop can take up 125 lb./ac. of available potassium. Of the K canola takes up, at least 75% is returned to the field in the residue.

Soil reserves: Canola is an excellent scavenger of K in the soil and because the relatively “young” Prairie soils continue to produce plant-available K through break-down of clay minerals, canola crops have rarely shown a response to K fertilizer. But if soil tests show less than 250 pounds per acre (125 ppm), canola may benefit from a K application.

Long-time Alberta soil scientist and fertilizer expert Ross McKenzie estimates that 20-25% of fields on the Canadian Prairies could have soil K levels in the deficiency range for canola. He says soils most likely to show K deficiency are intensively cropped, coarse textured (sandy loam) and tend to be in the higher precipitation regions in the Black and Gray soil zones.

Canola Encyclopedia chapter on potassium management

Micronutrients

Canola takes up more boron than other micronutrients, but amounts are still low. Tissue analysis of canola at flowering show sufficiency at these levels: 29 parts per million (ppm) for boron, 19 ppm for iron, 14 for manganese, 14 for zinc, 2.6 for copper and 0.02 for molybdenum.

The Canola Council of Canada boron trials, done as part of the Ultimate Canola Challenge for 2013-15, found no consistent yield benefit from boron treatment, including in those plots with very high yield results. Read more.

Canola Encyclopedia chapter on micronutrients management

Moisture

Moisture is a major limiting factor for canola yield potential and must be included when setting fertilizer rates and budgets. Although dependent on evapo-transpiration potential, the general rule is that canola needs an inch of available moisture through the growing season for every 4 bushels per acre of yield potential. A 50-bushel crop will need roughly 12 inches of moisture.

*Rigas Karamanos et al, “Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Sulfur Fertility of Hybrid Canola,” Journal of Plant Nutrition, 28: 1145-1161, 2005
**Personal conversation with Rigas Karamanos and U of M soil scientist Don Flaten, January 2018.

Further reading:

Canola Digest: Why are low-yielding areas low yielding?
Canola Digest: Post-emergent nitrogen reduces the seeding time crunch
Canola Digest: 5 steps to better fertility planning
Canola Digest: Banding N shows clear yield advantage…

Canola Watch